Almost-Human  05/27/06 @451

Very good render.. My only crit is that the line of wood and tip are not running in a straight line as they would when you took the pencil out of the sharpener?? Well I think it would be a straight line.... ( I dont use pencils ! )

Cigaro  05/27/06 @471

imo if it was straight it would be a bit too perfect some people sharpen their pencils with just a sharp knife Brian anyway...great render

Fyralath  05/27/06 @532

Very nice! Look like real pencil. Nice idea.

pegahoul  05/27/06 @535

Really looks like real pencils! Cool work!

armilar  05/27/06 @561

Oh my gosh this is incredible. Amaizng render! You sure made those pensils look realistic! The only one that doesn«t look so realistic to me i the purple one because I think the lightning should also be a bit in the wood. Still it's amazing. Congratulations for such amaizng job

ARZILLIER66  05/27/06 @587

super work I like it! i agree whit the sharpener comment .

Hklevjer  05/27/06 @752

Good!

baher  05/27/06 @753

great render !

Wapy  05/29/06 @708

greaT 1I would not think in this! Its' so obvious!!!

ThruMyEyez  05/30/06 @006

Very realistic and artistic. Nice work.

jfrancis  05/31/06 @130

The slight change of angle between the colored paint label and the wood is a nice detail. It catches a hint of light there. +9

Alena  05/31/06 @535

very realistic !!!

kittyKat  06/01/06 @079

looks almost like a photo

Zebu  06/01/06 @428

wouldnt it have been easier ot take a photo ? no really, very realistic render

coladelight  06/02/06 @119

Like the others said, the realism is stunning. Well done! Maridol + 10

sdavis75  06/06/06 @100

I was certain this was a photo when I first saw the thumbnail. No crits here. +10

Wallace  06/07/06 @991

Okay thats it! I'm seeing this thing popping up at top random artworks again and again. And now that I take a look at it, I'm in awe.... Stunning render! + 10

trevorm  06/12/06 @047

A very convincing render. Great diffuse shadows and radiousity. You also nailed all the surfaces textures!

arjun  08/16/06 @102

The term "illustration" just means it's being displayed or shown. This is NOT a render, people. It is a photograph. Sorry Kittomer, I had to say something. As for my crits. I like the clarity and colors.

PeaPod  08/16/06 @163

wow Very good. I like the lighting on the end of the yellow, light blue, and orange but the others look too shiny to me... maybe I just don't get shiny pencils

kittomer  09/16/06 @301

Arjun: This is a rendering, trust me.

jmillerdesign  01/03/07 @418

I know this is a bit late, but I got some time to look over past postings. I like this, very simple...yet extremely photoreal. Good job!