acida  12/05/06 @877

giving 10 it is lovely and dreamy. i find this very good... maybe a bit crop cuz the grass extends way too much.

SandraS  12/05/06 @881

This is fantastic. I thought it was a 3D work at first. The elements are so well intergrated with eachother, and the mood is dreamy and mysterious. I love your work Wonder too, but you've linked to the wrong artwork here.

GoldPaw  12/05/06 @911

Love it. Seems far better than "Wonder" to me although that one is good too.

Diegoth  12/05/06 @967

Excellent and inspiring

PMD  12/05/06 @980

Thanks so much for the kind words folks - I fixed the link. I wrestled with the grass acida, but in the end I decided to leave the foreground as 'long' for two reasons - one for composition, and two, because I wanted to push the boy back from the viewer - its his world, we just get to peek in

Daykan  12/06/06 @014

Amazing! beautiful work!

Martin777  12/06/06 @059

Great work. I prefer boy not in the middle only ... Tree and especially grass - amazing!

leloops  12/06/06 @409

its a breathtakingly beautiful work, the details of the huge tree blew me away =)

dullboy-d  12/06/06 @426

Wow I like this one, it brings up alot of feelings. Good job fellow creator +7

anastasia  12/07/06 @519

Fantastic work! Everything looks amazing! The colors and the execution are really great! The mood and the lighting on the child are perfect. Very impressive! Max score!

dullboy-d  12/07/06 @558

Great job, I know how much time it takes to create an effect of this scale, impressive that you took the time. 7+ for sure

siffert  12/07/06 @580

Very good work!

kynu  12/07/06 @677

this image is literally wonderful could you show us some details? I want to give this a big +10 but I cannot. (so +9) ...when will I able to do that?? : (

cbouchar  12/08/06 @277

I logged in just to vote for this. It's awesome. The details, the colours, the mood.... well executed.

cupcake  12/08/06 @869

Very Good +10

Aminal  12/08/06 @893

This picture made me smile in the worst time of my life. Thank you!

frankitu  12/08/06 @909

wooow! impressive!! +9/+9

PMD  12/09/06 @089

Thanks so much folks, its lovely to get such positive feedback. Aminal, I'm glad to make you smile, and I hope life isn't as bad as you make it sound. You have my best wishes and thoughts. Phil.

deManuel  12/09/06 @423

Awesome work. Love the atmosphere. +10

ThruMyEyez  12/11/06 @098

Beautiful, absolutely beautiful!!!

phospheratu  12/11/06 @424

Wonderful.

Cigaro  12/11/06 @602

really cute i love the colour scheme and that big tree

Bookzie  12/11/06 @913

wooow no comment. it is wonderfull...

dakoo  12/13/06 @498

Beautifully done !! top marks !!!

locutus  12/13/06 @583

This is absolutely wonderful! Really like the imagery with many things can be taken out of the story

Ikaa  12/15/06 @082

Wonderful work!

ananda  12/19/06 @989

What a wonderful magical piece you have created!

XeriuX  04/23/07 @760

i'm so amazed how people can do these manipulations.. its just so good! skilzzzzzzzzz great one!

PNKasim  04/27/07 @070

Mind boggling. I absolutely love it. Top marks all the way

Gavade  04/28/07 @077

Love it!

RobertVovk  04/29/07 @685

Wow, this reminds me of a childhood when watching my favorite cartoons of walking - talking trees. Nice one.

alinsa  05/01/07 @494

Wow, What do you do to do the grass? It's fantastic xD

Ringgold  05/03/07 @214

Woah! Great!

NKN  05/05/07 @209

Is the tree also a photograph??! +8/8

PMD  05/06/07 @406

Hi NKN,The tree is a combination of about 20 elements of tree photographs, mostly my own, with a huge amount of overpainting to match texture and light. Thanks for commenting! Phil.

pegahoul  05/08/07 @644

saw this on CGtalk a while ago! Very lovely!

Excorbac  05/09/07 @317

Very well done, although at least few folding of the boy's clothes would be welcome. His clothes seem rather 'flat'. I would have also cropped the grass. Otherwise very good lighting and very good ideas.

NunoDias  05/11/07 @875

Wonderfull image...great imagination and fantasy you give us....continue with the good work!!

aniocean  06/07/07 @697

Just spetacular

mangofeva  06/12/07 @526

looks gorgeous! the detail work is excellent.

redragon  12/15/07 @709

oh this is so beautiful!!

L-aura  06/16/08 @881

Wow, excellent.

L-aura  06/16/08 @882

Wow, excellent.

lillyfly06  08/05/08 @150

*_*