Interesting reflection...

Well, the shoes look very real. But I'm not feeling anything with this. Hmm. But nice shoes! ^^

cool work!!

love the black shoe more than red good realitic view ,but and i don`t felling nothing ,and don`t catch the concept and i love your privious work more may be the reflection in the ground would be better if it is not so rippled if i can say in that way,and to end this comment i`ll say that this is good work ,may be not your best but good and i am waiting for new work from you

wow! like the mixture of line art, photo manipulation, stunning combination

Hi Thomas,

I like how the simplicity of the legs helps you focus more on the product. I really like the reflection texture but I find that a bit more care was put into the shine of the black shoe than that of the red, but then again gouache gives you a little less flexibility so it's understandable. Nice Job!

nice, very nice

The shoes look like photographs, but the reflection kind of kills the minimalism of the piece for me. The position of the shoes is kind of bothering me too, I think if you took out the reflection and moved the shoes slightly lower in the frame it would look much nicer. The shoes look amazing though and I like the concept of the realistic shoes/minimal legs.

Edit - I just looked at the larger one. That one is perfect! +8

unique style of composition cool

Good Work -
Nice reflections on the ground - seems like standing on a glas floor.

Hi!
I just looked at the other critics, telling the different reflections on the shoes would bother them. But isn´t that caused on two different materials that the shoes are made of? Thought you´ve drawn shiny, natural leather (black) and patent leather (red). Love the photograph-like image, for this: high rate
But there´s a scarcity in the floor-reflection of the left black shoe.
Nevertheless: well done

well done.
I like the realistic look of the shoes more than the reflection.

@camikaze: But isn´t that caused on two different materials that the shoes are made of? - that's my guess, too

gr8 work

nice work. Very realistic looking shoes

awesomeness, they do look very realistic

Simple and nice!

great reflection i like the effects too. +10/10

I have a fetish for high heels man!

Great job!

The heel of the left red pump is a bit off
Other than that this really makes me happy

+ 10

Heels! Beautiful rendition, too, especially the black ones.

thx for all that feedback
guys

Good job, would be great for a wallpaper/advert

Great job on your black shoes, reflections too

nice shoes

It looks real good.
The highlights are looking very fine. Maybe you should overwork the position of the red ones a bit.

I wonder, where did you get the inspiration from^^

Anyway its a nice picture!
Keep it up.

looking really good, the pencil work on the shoes is incredible +10

Very realistic ^^

Actually, depending on how reflective the floor is it wouldn't matter what material the shoes are made of. If the floor is that polished and shiney, they'd reflect like a mirror. I like this image. Nicely done. I think what makes the red shoes' heal a bit off is the white highlight placement. Nice work.

bEAUTIFULLY Done! The black ones I like better becasue they seem more solid, however I like the stylized way the red ones are doen too. Very nice!
+9

Wauw, very realistic Nice how you did the legs

Legs are a great shape.Very ssssmmooth!!
+9