http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594 Copyright 2000-2008 GFXartist network / Brothersinart http://www.gfxartist.com http://images.gfxartist.com/gfx/GFXartist_64.png support@gfxartist.com en-us GFXartist Engine 1.0 60 Tue, 02 Dec 2008 21:07:23 EST http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#979822508 What decides what goes into Best Random Artwork? AshSammy http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#155240 OK this current voting system is the best of threes yes i really think the actual system is really good don't change it because people could make bad use of the negative vote or anything else... this one is excellent keep it!! NeozooM http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#16139 thanks for the extremely interesting proposals Martin http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#6613 for my part i suggest the possibility to know who had voted for our works but with the agreement of the voter (a check box next to the vote field) (know the amount of points given by a member is not necessary important I think), it can be interessant way to discover who are the voters and visit their gallery... many of us vote but they don't let comments... it's damage ! Smack http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#3632 and what if each time someone look at an art, he must vote? (and once by ip)?by this way, peoples who just look at an art, and are not friends or "enemy", should make the score more "real", or "normal" (sorry, i'm french, with bad english knowledge! ) mogh http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#1506 yah... my katherine painting is at -2 right now which doesn't make any sense when all i've gotten are good comments on it and when it used to be up to like, 35 or something. the negative voting system in general still gets me in some ways. like mongi said, it's too easy for some boner 12 year old to manipulate the votes around, or for someone to just go give a negative vote just because they didn't like a comment someone said on their art. then again, i like the top10 feature and the elite gallery feature and i can't really think of any other way to determine that. louisfinazzo http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#1060 Having to ask your friends to vote on you makes you a pretty crappy artist. We kept voting anonymous so nobody can see who voted what score. Maybe we also implement a 'favorites' thing, but it's still not clear to me what it means, and/or how it works, so if somebody can explain me...? Martijn http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#1057 I giving scores isn't good fundamentally, it's art. DevArt is better since you don't really give scores, you just say whcih are your favourites, which I like better. Here there are still people asking friends to give them high scores and they get on the top list. You can also put down others without reason just to get your own pic to the top. Oh well. mongi http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#1034 Thanks... If nobody else has comments I'll put this one in the FAQ, and lets hope nobody else has complains about it... Martijn http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#1009 very good voting system i must say. seems fair to me at least. keep up the good work SkeLeton http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#993 You guys definitely did your homework on this one. Don't change it! Digitalmar http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#992 This voting system rocks!! i can't think of anyway that you could make it better... GJ!! Dead-Astronaut http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#982 yah, i'm now a lot more happy with the current system now that it's been explained thuroughly. it makes a lot more sense now and my cocerns are no longer. appreciate you taking the time to explain this to everyone. louisfinazzo http://www.gfxartist.com/general/general_news/594#977 I like the current vote system, i agree it is the best from the three. interface